| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2012 41-7 | Feliciano 6-2, 3.57 | Mastroianni 8-2, 2.11 | Wills 8-0, 2.60 | Nevárez 6-1, 4.73 | Russell 3-0, 1.00 | Delgado 18 SV, 0.37 | Delgado 23 G, 0.37 | Schafer 19 G, 4.03 | Cahill 17 G, 7.08 | | 2013 33-16 | Feliciano 5-0, 2.55 | Mastroianni 5-1, 3.05 | Wills 8-0, 2.06 | Russell 4-3, 3.32 | Delgado 6-2, 1.51 | Schafer 9 SV, 4.26 | López 22 G, 9.82 | Morín 21 G, 7.18 | Schafer 18 G, 4.26 | | 2014 29-19 | Feliciano 3-2, 3.41 | Mastroianni 4-3, 3.19 | Delgado 3-3, 3.28 | Bugbie 4-1, 6.26 | Driskill 4-2, 4.21 | Schafer 11 SV, 1.50 | Brown 30 G, 3.90 | Fleming 29 G, 8.78 | Morín 23 G, 8.55 | | 2015 22-26 | Delgado 7-3, 2.41 | Feliciano 4-3, 3.06 | Glenn 1-8, 7.92 | Patterson 6-1, 3.72 | Bugbie 2-2, 7.41 | Brown 10 SV, 4.32 | Fleming 31 G, 5.70 | Aponte 24 G, 4.78 | Montoya 22 G, 8.10 | | 2016 19-29 | Glenn 2-6, 5.82 | Murray 3-4, 3.12 | Bugbie 3-1, 4.38 | Montoya 1-5, 5.71 | Rodríguez 1-5, 4.55 | Driskill 7 SV, 9.19 | Fleming 28 G, 4.60 | González 26 G, 4.30 | Morín 22 G, 2.52 | |