| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2012 24-24 | Conway 3-3, 4.85 | Harrell 4-2, 3.62 | Ortíz 3-3, 2.90 | Martínez 3-2, 3.38 | Orozco 2-1, 3.86 | Carver 6 SV, 4.09 | Martin 26 G, 5.74 | Cusack 25 G, 7.94 | Mooney 23 G, 2.35 | | 2013 25-23 | Baker 3-2, 1.71 | Conway 2-5, 3.43 | Harrell 4-0, 2.12 | Orozco 5-4, 2.04 | Ortíz 4-1, 4.84 | Carver 12 SV, 5.86 | Martínez 30 G, 4.54 | Parks 27 G, 5.26 | Carver 26 G, 5.86 | | 2014 22-26 | Orozco 7-3, 4.39 | Conway 1-4, 5.03 | Baker 3-1, 1.87 | Jacobs 3-5, 5.77 | Miller 0-4, 6.50 | Ortíz 8 SV, 1.01 | Parks 27 G, 6.08 | Carver 26 G, 3.98 | Mooney 25 G, 8.14 | | 2015 25-23 | Jacobs 5-3, 1.81 | Miller 1-2, 4.92 | Ortíz 5-1, 3.44 | Williams 0-7, 9.34 | Conway 2-2, 2.58 | Quinn 10 SV, 2.28 | Mooney 29 G, 8.78 | Parks 28 G, 6.82 | Vega 28 G, 7.76 | | 2016 30-18 | Armstrong 9-1, 1.36 | Conway 3-2, 3.41 | Jacobs 3-3, 4.82 | Miller 2-1, 2.52 | Ortíz 1-3, 2.54 | Ortíz 9 SV, 2.54 | Howard 27 G, 7.33 | Moyer 23 G, 7.11 | Quinn 22 G, 2.25 | |