| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2012 23-25 | Acosta 1-4, 6.70 | Hernández 5-3, 3.70 | Johnson 2-5, 6.26 | López 1-5, 9.15 | Smith 4-2, 6.41 | Amore 7 SV, 3.09 | Duncan 29 G, 4.46 | Kathirithamby 26 G, 4.54 | Stewart 25 G, 3.18 | | 2013 29-19 | Hernández 5-2, 3.80 | Martin 5-4, 3.39 | López 2-4, 5.96 | Smith 6-2, 3.45 | Cook 1-3, 4.25 | Amore 11 SV, 3.05 | Kathirithamby 28 G, 5.28 | Duncan 27 G, 7.28 | Johnson 25 G, 8.14 | | 2014 32-16 | Hernández 7-3, 3.11 | Martin 5-2, 4.41 | López 2-5, 7.05 | Smith 6-2, 3.81 | Castillo 4-1, 7.15 | Amore 12 SV, 0.68 | Duncan 26 G, 3.35 | Allen 25 G, 0.96 | Amore 22 G, 0.68 | | 2015 31-17 | Morris 6-2, 2.42 | Smith 4-4, 3.63 | Castillo 5-3, 7.59 | López 5-0, 4.76 | Ford 3-2, 3.64 | Allen 12 SV, 2.31 | Duncan 30 G, 3.27 | Sunalp 25 G, 2.76 | Johnson 22 G, 2.45 | | 2016 35-13 | Emery 4-1, 3.22 | Morris 6-1, 2.65 | Harrison 4-1, 6.13 | Smith 2-3, 5.04 | Bryant 6-0, 2.45 | Allen 8 SV, 2.89 | Ford 29 G, 4.33 | Callahan 24 G, 0.84 | Walden 21 G, 4.50 | |