| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2012 17-31 | Keller 2-3, 2.90 | Barnett 3-3, 4.03 | Caraballo 2-4, 4.48 | Green 0-10, 9.00 | Kent 0-0, 3.00 | Short 5 SV, 1.76 | Burke 30 G, 5.60 | Flores 29 G, 8.90 | Brandt 27 G, 7.45 | | 2013 19-29 | Barnett 5-2, 3.31 | Kent 1-6, 7.05 | Brandt 4-3, 5.33 | Sexton 1-7, 6.80 | Yánez 3-3, 4.04 | Burke 5 SV, 7.04 | William 27 G, 5.33 | Spencer 25 G, 7.34 | Flores 24 G, 6.46 | | 2014 25-23 | O'Herlihy 4-3, 4.83 | Walters 3-3, 7.35 | Yánez 4-5, 4.61 | Nara 3-2, 7.66 | Burke 2-0, 4.98 | Lee 5 SV, 3.48 | Crowley 30 G, 5.71 | William 30 G, 9.40 | Pérez 29 G, 6.30 | | 2015 29-19 | Wadley 6-1, 4.48 | Franklin 3-4, 4.13 | Crowley 1-2, 6.29 | O'Herlihy 5-3, 4.05 | Strong 1-4, 6.70 | Yánez 11 SV, 4.43 | Spencer 30 G, 5.25 | Walters 27 G, 6.11 | Vásquez 26 G, 5.54 | | 2016 24-24 | Franklin 4-2, 2.99 | Wadley 4-3, 3.27 | Foster 5-2, 3.43 | Harris 3-4, 4.47 | Crowley 1-4, 7.53 | Vásquez 7 SV, 8.05 | Hayes 32 G, 6.23 | Wonnacott 26 G, 12.73 | Payne 25 G, 9.10 | |